November 15, 1999
College Trashes Student Newspaper
"Article I - Congress shall make no law ... abridging
the freedom of speech, or of the press..."
By Laura Esterly News
Editor
SKIDMORE COLLEGE, New York - Approximately 1200
missing copies of The Skidmore News were removed from Case Center
racks early on Monday by Admissions Director Mary Lou Bates.
The issue featured a cover story on Skidmore's
reaction to possible hate crimes that have occurred on campus, as
well as an editorial written by Managing Editor Curtis Morrow called,
"12 Reasons to go to a Community College."
Bates apologized for her decision to remove the
papers in a letter to the community on Thursday.
"My motivation in removing what I deemed
to be potentially offensive material in no way reflected an intent
to censor or inhibit the exchange of information within the community,
but rather to limit the offence to families outside the Skidmore
community, who were here at the invitation of the Admissions office,
and to whom I felt a responsibility," she said.
Monday was an open house sponsored by admissions
for prospective students and their parents.In response to Bates'
decision to remove the papers, President Jamie Studley said, "I'm
disappointed that the papers were removed.
The college policies are in support of an open
press, whether radio, television or printed media. But I'm also
pleased the person who did it realized that it wasn't good judgment."
"What it tells us is that it's important
to keep the airwaves open in a sense," said Studley. "I
appreciate that we and The Skidmore News both have the same commitment
to making information available to the community."
Morrow noticed that more than half of the papers
printed each week were missing from bins on Monday afternoon. "It
was such a clean job," said Morrow, "I knew there was
no way that it was students and faculty [who] had taken them all.
Usually there are crumpled leftovers."
Morrow, believing the copies to be stolen, called
Skidmore News Editor in Chief Shawn McCormack to see whether he
had received a phone call from administration about the papers.
"I didn't believe him when he told me that
they were stolen, " said McCormack. Eventually, however, Morrow
convinced him that investigation was necessary.
The editors talked to custodian Gary Moore, who
confirmed that the papers were empty when he came in for his shift
that started at 7 a.m.
"It helped that we talked to custodians,
because they could tell us exactly when they noticed they were gone,"
he said. "I was trying to nail the exact time, to really know
they were stolen and didn't just move on their own."
Morrow wrote a statement of the theft that appeared
in all-campus Student Announcements over e-mail Tuesday, and looked
into obtaining the tape from the Adirondack Trust ATM surveillance
camera. Morrow said that Adirondack Trust Company was reluctant
to provide the tape.
The editors notified the Saratoga Springs Police
Department, and called area newspapers about the story. Assistant
Director of College Relations Robert Kimmerle found out about the
stolen papers when Kenneth Crowe, a reporter with the Albany Times
Union, called him Wednesday night.
"I drew a blank when he asked how I heard.
I told him I'd look into it and call him back."
By Thursday morning, Kimmerle said he "learned
that the Director of Admissions Mary Lou Bates and another staff
member or two," had taken the papers. "She admitted taking
the papers right away, that pretty much took the mystery out of
it," said Kimmerle.
The issues were gone from the News racks before
most students were even awake for classes Monday morning. Kate Nahon
'00 said, "I never got to read it. I was a bit dismayed."
Students were left to guess about whether the
issues were extremely popular, or stolen.
"I could definitely see someone doing it
[stealing the papers] in reaction to the stuff that's been going
on here...I can't see them [administration] ever doing that...I'd
see it as a student attack on students," said Megan Murphy
'01.
Matt Moore '01 was convinced that the issues had
been stolen. "My first guess was that it was someone within
the Administration. I definitely didn't think it was students. I
mean, what would a student do with all those papers?" said
Moore.
Comment
Copyright 1999 The
Skidmore News. All rights reserved.
|